I am considering purchasing a new shotgun for shooting sporting and have decided on either a new Miroku or Perazzi. Having shot the MK38 Sporter and Trap my preference would be for the latter, especially with 32" fixed choke barrels. I think that the Miroku is absolutely excellent value for the money. The only criticism I have of the Miroku is that the trigger pull leaves a lot to be desired but I am sure that a competent gunsmith could improve this. I also like the MX2000 S. It has the look and feel of a quality shotgun. The trigger pulls are excellent, light and crisp. What I am struggling to get my head round is the price difference between the two guns. Both guns appear to be well engineered and built too last. Is the Perazzi MX2000 S so much better than the Miroku as to justify it's price tag, three and a bit times more than the cost of a new MK38 Grade 5 Trap gun? Before I make my decision I would like to know, preferably from Perazzi owners, if the additional expense of the Perazzi has been a worthwhile investment.
Well that ignited a lively debate didn't it?
To get back to the core of your question, either gun will break clays equally effectively for sure. Both are well made and engineered to last a lot longer than any of us are likely to live. The Perazzi is just made with exquisite attention to detail and the elegance of the design is undoubtedly more challenging to manufacture, reflected in the cost, which as you have noted is considerably higher than the Miroku. Slip the stock off a Perazzi and you will discover that the components of the action are as beautifully finished as the outside of the gun and yet rarely seen by most owners. The broken trigger spring story is related to the MX8 family of guns, when the guns are new are a pair of spare springs is provided along with the special tool needed to pop them in. The MX2000S you are considering uses coil springs and are regarded as extremely reliable.
Break the MK38 open and you will see square holes in the floor of the action that correspond with lumps in the bottom of the barrels, beautifully machined and finished so that when the action is closed the joins are all but invisible. Do the same to the Perazzi and discover the floor of the action is completely smooth, no holes at all, the action locks itself tight with an ingenious solution that compensates for wear, exquisite, necessarily expensive because its more complicated to machine. The barrels of a Perazzi are still, to this day, assembled by hand, it takes time, absolute perfection is expensive.
You can buy a lovely Miroku off the shelf and with a little luck it will probably fit you and all will be well and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. For the Perazzi you can buy off the shelf too, but many owners, noting the considerable investment take a trip to Italy and get fitted in the factory/try their gun on the indoor range for the ultimate fit. The additional cost is just a flight and a night in a hotel. Most people don't realise that there isn't really a 'standard Perazzi' but rather a myriad of options, 5 different bore sizes for 12g, different ribs, slopes, sights, stocks, palm swells, grips, the balance point, inter-barrel webbing and even the final weight of the barrel assembly (stamped on the item) is user definable.
Some of us have discovered John Jeffries at HPX and have the fitting process completed in the UK - think of it as akin to buying a Ferrari and having it supplied by a tuning shop to an exact specification, unique to you.
Finally, it's your money, your choice. There is a curious pleasure in getting a beautiful gun out of the cabinet, knowing it was made for you and that it's purpose is about to be fulfilled, many never get the chance or have the opportunity to experience that. If you do, then enjoy every moment, you surely deserve it.