thats right no neck..
Possibly a silver Pigeon new or second hand as my first gun as i held a new one and it felt great
that two inch rule was in my mind when i picked up the silver pigeon but i noticed my thumb knuckle was around 4" away from my nose :mellow:
dont get me wrong im not that muscular now, just large , so i live in hope...
If you like the feel of them, then you can't go too far wrong. That is what I have. Beware that a secondhand one, will likely not be the same gun as the SP1, that is a new gun.
Make sure you get a sporter model, not a game gun.
Do look at the new Browning 725 similar money. Again, the sporter not the hunter
Don't go longer than 30 inch barrels.
If you are in a decent shop, get them to take off the butt pad on the Beretta, this will take off about 18mm and then be closer to the length you would need.
As you can see by the pic I posted, I cut mine down with a bandsaw (when it was less than a month old!)..but I was fitting a recoil reducer.
Having no neck might add other issues, if it means you mount the gun low in the shoulder, so you can get your cheek on it...but all of this is fixable!
Either of those guns would never need to be replaced or upgraded...rather than if you spent less on something...not so good...then it seems less worth the effort and cost to fit the gun, because you might change it...but will then affect your shooting.
Don't throw money away, but don't penny pinch either.